How should Christians react to ‘The Golden Compass’ movie?


Question: “How should Christians react to ‘The Golden Compass’ movie?”

Answer: How should Christians react to “The Golden Compass,” the new movie based on a book by Phillip Pullman? Questions are being raised about the content of the film, given the anti-religious slant of the books and their author. The book series “His Dark Materials” on which “The Golden Compass” is based is aggressively anti-Christian. There are ample reasons for Christians to avoid supporting this series through movie tickets or book sales. It would be counterproductive to stage protests, overt boycotts, or other measures, since that would only give free publicity to the studio selling the film. At the same time, “The Golden Compass” has to be taken seriously by Christian families because the source material is explicitly anti-Christian, and targeted at children. Christian parents and children alike should be prepared to answer some of the false claims made by this series.

The Golden Compass is the first book in a trilogy called “His Dark Materials.” The author, Philip Pullman, is a vocal atheist who is particularly critical of Catholicism. In the trilogy, the church is evil, controlling, ignorant, intolerant of dissent, and sadistic. Pullman does not disguise the church as some other entity, but attacks it more or less directly. The books use terms like “original sin,” “baptized as a Christian,” “Vatican Council,” and “magisterium.” “The Golden Compass” is, compared to its sequels, subtle in its attacks on Christianity. The second and third books become more and more “preachy,” and more overtly hostile to Christianity. The movie can be expected to follow the same pattern: the anti-religious rhetoric in “The Golden Compass” will likely be subtle, or even downplayed. Successive movies will not be able to do the same thing without completely changing the story.

Pullman leaves no doubt about his beliefs and his intentions. He has been referred to as “The Pied Piper of Atheism” for his powerful ability to tell children’s stories and his distaste for religion. Are the books deliberately atheistic? Pullman has stated, “My books are about killing God,” Are they anti-Christian? Again, Pullman has said, “I’m trying to undermine the basis of Christian belief,” and “If there is a God, and he is as the Christians describe him, then he deserves to be put down and rebelled against.” During the book trilogy, a major character intones, “The Christian religion is a powerful and convincing mistake, that’s all.” It would be dishonest for anyone to claim that this trilogy, which “The Golden Compass” is a part of, is not deliberately anti-Christian.

The messages conveyed in the series are not compatible with a Christian outlook, either. The main character is named Lyra, because she is a habitual liar. Her lies are intended for purely selfish reasons, and there is never a point in the trilogy where she learns that such things are wrong. Part of her journey in the series includes having a sexual experience as very young teen, which the author portrays as a part of her outgrowing religious control. She represents a “second Eve,” whose rebellion against God is meant to be applauded as a quest for knowledge.

The Golden Compass, along with any other works connected to the “His Dark Material’s” trilogy, are certainly anti-Christian both in content and intent. The advertising of this movie has been very misleading about the religious message it conveys. The trilogy, both books and presumably the movies, introduce atheistic themes gradually, luring children into the story as a way to slip the message in. Advertisements are comparing “The Golden Compass” to “The Lord of the Rings” and “The Chronicles of Narnia.” Pullman’s work is, morally, the polar opposite of Tolkien and Lewis. Scholastic has even created a school curriculum set, including all three books, as a part of public school reading programs.

Works such as these need to be countered, but only in a Christ-like way. At their core, the “His Dark Materials” stories are a fantasy setting for the atheistic worldview, where death is the end of everything, all morals are subjective, and any idea of God is a tool for evil. Christians should not respond in ways that play into Pullman’s stereotypes of believers as ignorant, oppressive, and bigoted. A loving, polite response combined with truthful answers can turn the release of “The Golden Compass” into a great opportunity to witness for Christ’s sake.


3 Comments on How should Christians react to ‘The Golden Compass’ movie?

  1. As in all things, Christians and nonbelievers should approach this movie with open minds (preferably after reading the book). Its criticism of organized religion is legitimate, and shows the proven dangers of allowing faith to contaminate government. These are lessons our children desperately need to be exposed to in a nation where religious indoctrination supplants critical thinking.

    If you’re a Christian, the best thing you could possibly do for your child is fairly represent the alternatives when discussing your own faith.

  2. The da vinci code movie came out while I was in Philippines and I had little to no interest in seeing that movie either just for curiosity sake i did. I just thought the movie was boring. he relied too much on sensationalism and not enough on actual good writing. I found it exceedingly predictable, which a good spy thriller type novel should never be. However, the controversy about the film “aren’t we supposed to be boycotting that movie?” as the discussions of the Church’s teachings were apparently too radical. My first reaction was that of disappointment and anger. In thinking about it and realizing this may be an opportunity to share, Jesus used your email to seal it for me. How many times in the past has there been something that goes against all we know and believe and it opened the door to share His truth? (but I was too busy fusing about it to see what Jesus was doing and what I should do.) Jesus can and will use anything to bring the lost to Him. We never have to approach any subject with defense or argument, we have to approach it with the backdrop of the cross right behind us. Jesus will give us all we need to show and share Him. Our energy will best be served by praying for the man responsible for this, Phillip Pullman a staunch atheist belonging to the secular humanist societies. Reading about him made me very sad, what happened in his life that he carries so much hate? Changing his heart is something only Jesus can do. Lets all commit to praying for him

  3. I certainly found Narnia to be preachy, but that didn’t stop me from reading the books. I don’t have much interest in this movie, and it doesn’t sound like it’s a good film just in general. But it’s telling the difference in responses between how the supposedly “militant” atheists responded to Narnia films (i.e. pretty much not at all) compared to how Christians are extremely up in arms about this Materials film.

    You also haven’t done much in the way of showing that the story is “morally the opposite” of the themes in Rings and even Narnia. Friendship, fighting evil, making sacrifices to save others all seem to be the basic character themes of all these stories.

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: